Games Like Pentiment
Quick Answer
The closest games to Pentiment are Disco Elysium, Return of the Obra Dinn, The Case of the Golden Idol, Norco and Citizen Sleeper. Below are 10 picks with the reason for each — what carries over from Pentiment, and what does not.
What Made Pentiment Work
Pentiment is a murder mystery in 16th-century Bavaria drawn like an illuminated manuscript, with no combat and no inventory puzzles. You are a journeyman artist, you have limited days, and the evidence never resolves into certainty — you accuse someone and live with it. The typefaces change with who is speaking. It is a game about how history gets written by the people who survive it.
10 Games Like Pentiment
1.Disco Elysium
The other great game where the mechanics are conversation, memory and the shape of your own head.
More about this game →2.Return of the Obra Dinn
Deduction with no hand-holding and a visual style just as committed.
More about this game →3.The Case of the Golden Idol
Pure deduction, stripped of everything else, and very good at it.
More about this game →5.Citizen Sleeper
Limited days, hard choices, and a narrative that moves whether you are ready or not.
More about this game →6.Kentucky Route Zero
If the art direction and the writing were the point rather than the mystery.
More about this game →7.Paradise Killer
An open murder investigation where you decide when you have enough to accuse.
More about this game →8.Her Story
A crime reconstructed from fragments, with the same refusal to confirm you got it right.
More about this game →9.Night in the Woods
A small town, a slow year, and writing carrying the entire game.
More about this game →10.What Remains of Edith Finch
Short, hand-crafted, and every chapter changes how it is played.
More about this game →
This list is in the free app
Games like Pentiment, with every reason, works offline in JustLikeGames — plus a pick for tonight and a backlog tracker.
Free · iPhone & Android · no account
How These Picks Match Pentiment
Pentiment is catalogued here as a Western RPG and art-led game on the Xbox Series X|S. All ten picks share at least one of its genre tags — ten adventures and two RPGs among them.
Disco Elysium, Return of the Obra Dinn, The Case of the Golden Idol, Norco, Citizen Sleeper, Kentucky Route Zero, Paradise Killer, Her Story, Night in the Woods and What Remains of Edith Finch are from small or self-published studios.
| Game | Genre | Shares with Pentiment |
|---|---|---|
| Disco Elysium | RPG, Adventure, Indie | Adventure, RPG |
| Return of the Obra Dinn | Puzzle, Adventure, Indie | Adventure |
| The Case of the Golden Idol | Puzzle, Adventure, Indie | Adventure |
| Norco | Adventure, Puzzle, Indie | Adventure |
| Citizen Sleeper | RPG, Adventure, Indie | Adventure, RPG |
| Kentucky Route Zero | Adventure, Indie, Casual | Adventure |
| Paradise Killer | Adventure, Puzzle, Indie | Adventure |
| Her Story | Adventure, Puzzle, Indie | Adventure |
| Night in the Woods | Adventure, Platformer, Indie | Adventure |
| What Remains of Edith Finch | Adventure, Indie, Casual | Adventure |
Buy This Game
* Affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Support Justlikegames
Made by one person, for free
I run Justlikegames pretty much for free — covering hosting, APIs, and the hours spent writing recommendation lists by hand. There are no paywalls, no intrusive popups, and no "premium" tier. If the site has helped you find your next favorite game, a coffee goes a long way toward keeping it that way.
Buy me a coffeeEven $3 covers a day of API costs. Thank you 💛
If You Love Pentiment, Try These
No similar games found yet. Check back soon!
How We Picked These Games
Our recommendations come from a multi-tier system: hand-curated lists for retro classics, tag-based matching for niche overlap, then genre fallback as a safety net. Nothing on this page was picked by a single algorithm in isolation.
Read our full editorial guidelines for how we evaluate every game on this site.
Frequently Asked Questions
More Xbox Series X Games Like Pages
Explore Other Consoles
Get Game Recs Weekly
Top picks, hidden gems, and deals — straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.
